25 Mistakes Fans Completely Missed In One Tree Hill

Summary

• High school dramas like One Tree Hill often have continuity errors fans enjoy spotting.
• Characteristic mistakes like changing locker rules and teleporting pom-poms are common in long-running series.
• Details like disappearing tattoos and changing shoes show the challenges of filming TV shows.

Full of teenage drama before it transitioned into being a full-on prime-time soap opera, One Tree Hill became known for a handful of events. It launched the acting career of former MTV VJ Hilarie Burton, made Sophia Bush a household name, snagged Chad Michael Murray from Gilmore Girls, and brought its young audience a selection of pretty great music. The series follows Murray’s Lucas Scott and his half-brother Nathan Scott (James Lafferty) alongside their friends as they come of age in the small town of Tree Hill, where basketball is a way of life.

Today, being able to binge-watch (and rewatch) a television show is something audiences couldn’t easily do even a decade ago. With the ability to more closely scrutinize a series comes the ability to spot errors in the program fans might have missed when it initially aired. Here, that includes items moving in a scene or instances where the circumstances of the show contradict themselves. Mistakes are inevitable in a series that runs as long as One Tree Hill, and for some fans, spotting them makes for an interesting pastime that doesn’t detract from their enjoyment of the series.

Changing Locker Rules

High schools across the United States have rules for locker assignments. Some schools base those assignments on what year the student is in or which classroom they’re in at a certain time of day, while others allow students to choose their own locker. Tree Hill, however, simply assigned lockers in alphabetical order at the beginning of the series.

Haley’s locker moved next to Lucas and Nathan’s at the start of a new school year. The explanation for that was her name change. When she became Haley James Scott, she fell in line with Lucas and Nathan Scott. Interestingly, later in the high school seasons, Brooke, Peyton, and Rachel’s lockers were all near the Scotts at one point. That made no sense given their last names were all over the alphabet as Davis, Sawyer, and Gatina.

This is a relatively easy-to-spot continuity error for fans watching from the beginning, but it also might not have been an error in the true sense of the word. It was likely a decision made to make filming the characters in a group easier with the line about alphabetical locker assignments simply ignored.

Teleporting Pom Poms

When Haley became a cheerleader, it was a result of another cheerleader’s injury in episode six. With Brooke medicated after the game, Haley, Peyton, and Brooke all ride back to Tree Hill together. While Brooke’s storylines wouldn’t start moving forward until much later, this was the start of the trio becoming friends.

A heavily medicated Brooke is not the best passenger. While annoying Haley and Peyton with her antics, she throws her pom-poms out the window. In one shot, they’re thrown from the driver’s side of the car. When the camera angle changes to show the car from the outside, though, they’re thrown from the passenger side of the car. It’s likely a product of the external car shots taking place at a different time than the internal ones, and an editor didn’t catch the mistake, but the audience certainly will.

A Jumping Bag

When television shows film, they usually have to get multiple takes of the same scenes. That might be a result of getting different camera angles to highlight different characters in a conversation or getting different performances out of the actors. When multiple takes of the same scene are filmed, everything is supposed to be placed right back where it started as the scene films again. Unfortunately, that doesn’t always happen. One instance of that is Haley’s jumping bag in One Tree Hill.

In the seventh episode of the first season, she gets ready to leave a studying session with Nathan. During the scene, her bag just doesn’t stay still. The strap moves from one shoulder to another and across her chest faster than she would have been able to move it between shots. It’s not a huge error that detracts from the story, but it can be distracting for more observant viewers.

The Impossible Email

TV viewers and movie fans understand they have to suspend some disbelief when they watch science fiction and fantasy. They don’t always expect it outside of those genres. Dramas can have their share of suspension of disbelief too, especially when something happens in the show that’s impossible in the real world.

In One Tree Hill’s first season, Lucas drafted an email to his mother. As a business owner, Karen’s email was tied to her restaurant. Lucas emailed her using “karen’scafe@hotmail.com”. Though technology is (slightly) more advanced since the show premiered, most email hosts still won’t allow special characters like apostrophes or accented letters in addresses. Karen’s email couldn’t exist.

Of course, the easiest explanation here is that the production team likely didn’t want a real-world email address being used, creating the seeming error. If they didn’t use a real-world email address, fans couldn’t claim it or email it thinking it would be connected to the show.

A Vanishing Tattoo

When actors have tattoos that their characters do not, they often have to be covered up with makeup or clothing. If they aren’t, they’re written into a show. For example, Matthew Fox’s real tattoo was written into the mythology of Lost so makeup artists wouldn’t have to waste time covering it up on a regular basis. So was Tyler Posey’s in Teen Wolf. On the other hand, Claudia Jessie of Bridgerton has tattoos covered up before she is in costume to prevent them from accidentally being seen by viewers.

At one point, Lucas Scott decided to be a little rebellious and get himself a tattoo on One Tree Hill. He supposedly got the word “fun” tattooed on his arm in Chinese lettering. In reality, the Mandarin characters are the equivalent of the word “have,” but what the Lucas Scott tattoo actually means is not the mistake here.

Instead, it’s whether or not Lucas actually has a tattoo. Once the storyline made it into the show, the tattoo would disappear and reappear throughout the series. To be fair, Lucas spends a lot of time in long sleeves. Also, the tattoo had to be applied on Chad Michael Murray for each scene as it was used to cover up the actor’s real tattoo instead of writing his own tattoo into the show.

Lipstick Changes

As season one came to an end, the show went through many changes. Nathan and Haley were truly an item, Nathan had his “own” apartment, and Lucas and Peyton were busy figuring things out. The number of changes the show went through almost equaled the number of times Haley’s lipstick changed in an episode 20 scene.

Nathan and Haley decided to throw a party at his new apartment, and in preparation for it, Haley stopped by to drop off some groceries. While talking to Nathan, though, her lipstick constantly changed throughout the scene. Depending on which camera was on her, she had either thickly lined and dark lipstick or thinly lined light lipstick.

Makeup errors like this are actually not common in One Tree Hill. It likely means that the scene was filmed over at least two different days, which means at least two different makeup applications. The makeup on one of those days might have actually been done for a different scene in the show entirely, so the error was unavoidable unless the decision was made to redo Haley’s makeup yet again.

Lengthening Hair

One sure sign that a television series filmed scenes for an episode out of sequence is hair length. One Tree Hill’s season one finale, “The Games That Play Us” demonstrated that well.

The episode sees Lucas and Nathan struggle to deal with their father as their basketball coach, while Haley and Nathan make a serious decision about their relationship. If all that drama wasn’t enough, Lucas’ hair also causes some of its own. Throughout the entire episode, Lucas’ hair gets longer, shorter, then longer again. Chad Michael Murray clearly got a haircut before he wrapped for the season on the show.

This noticeable difference in hair is actually why a lot of actors are contracted to keep their hair a certain way when they sign on to a television series or movie franchise. It’s to eliminate errors that might result. It’s also why projects that shoot over a longer amount of time might just employ the use of wigs instead of forcing the actor to maintain one look.

Time Traveling Wedding

At the end of season one, Lucas gets quite the shock from his best friend and his half-brother. Haley informs Lucas that the two got married the night before following the basketball play-offs. It ended the season with a shocker for fans, but once the series returned for season two, details about the wedding expanded.

The problem is that during season two flashbacks to the first One Tree Hill wedding ceremony, the sun shone in the sky. Nathan and Haley couldn’t have gotten married when the sun was out. By the time the basketball game ended, the sun had already set.

Like many of the continuity errors in One Tree Hill, there’s likely a production reason behind this one. While the series featured plenty of scenes filmed at night, it’s much easier to have a scene filmed in daylight instead of having to rig lighting and fix the coloring after the fact to make a night scene visible for fans. Many CW series feature very dark nighttime scenes that have had consistent complaints from fans about visibility over the years, like Arrow. One Tree Hill deciding to film the scene in the daylight was really ahead of the complaints.

Audio Without Video

Audio dialogue replacement, or ADR, occurs when a piece of dialogue isn’t audible on camera. Actors frequently have to head into a recording studio after filming to record pieces of dialogue for scenes they’ve already filmed. Sometimes when a television show films, dialogue choices change after the fact as script changes are made during the editing process. That may have been the case for one scene in the season two premiere.

During an early scene in the episode, Nathan and Haley chat in bed while it rains outside. As they do, Haley’s voice says the words, “maybe so,” to Nathan, but her mouth never moves. It’s possible the line was added in to fill in the conversation later, rather than an actual mistake in the scene. It’s just unfortunate that the dialogue is added when it’s obvious she’s not speaking. Otherwise, fans likely would never have known.

The Magic iPod

Before everyone’s music was stored in their iPhone or streamed on Spotify, Apple introduced iPods. The early generations of the iPod really took off when One Tree Hill was in its heyday. With a huge focus on music in the series, new musical artists got attention and iPods got plenty of product placement. During the season two episode “The Truth Doesn’t Make A Noise”, Lucas spent some time listening to music on his own down by the river court. He carried the iPod around with him after the fact.

Later in the episode, Keith stopped by to drop the iPod off with the explanation that Lucas left it in his truck. How could he leave it if he was actively using it earlier and didn’t put it in Keith’s truck? It’s entirely possible there was a scene that was cut from the episode that could have explained the error, but fans may never know.

Changing Hairstyles

It can be very obvious that filming for a particular scene occurred over two different time periods if there was one major change in one of the central characters. For example, if the person in question has a complete change in clothing or hairstyle. While makeup and clothing mistakes don’t happen often in the series, changing hairstyles in One Tree Hill definitely pop up quite a bit.

In the season three episode “Locked Hearts and Hand Grenades”, Haley heads back into the music studio with Chris Keller but finds herself having a little trouble getting her feelings to translate into music. Eventually, Chris places Haley’s name on a map in the café meant to depict great musicians. As they discuss her name on the map, Haley’s hair goes from being in a high ponytail to loose and messy repeatedly.

Visible Crew Members

Main character Peyton goes through a lot in One Tree Hill and has a unique family situation in the series. Living with her father, she spends a lot of time alone since he travels for work. She believed her birth mother was no longer in the land of the living, but it turned out that was a lie. The truth was revealed in the third season of the show.

Peyton actually meets Ellie in season three, discovering that she and her mother have a lot in common, including their taste in music. When Peyton takes a road trip to check on Ellie, her mother shows Peyton her record collection. As Peyton and Ellie head in to look at her records though, there’s a split second where a member of the filming crew is in the shot. It’s so quick that if an audience member blinks though, they’ll miss them.

Repeated Actions

When the same scene is shot from different angles, the exact same movements and dialogue appear on camera over and over again. If an editor isn’t careful, it can seem like a character repeats the same action when the camera angle changes in the finished product. That’s exactly what happens to Brooke in the episode “Brave New World”.

When Lucas and Peyton return from their road trip to check on Ellie, Lucas takes Brooke to the river court so she can see part of his life that she hasn’t been involved in before. Brooke walks over to sit with Mouth, and when the camera angle changes, she walks over to sit with Mouth again, even though she was already there. While it’s great to see Brooke and Mouth start their friendship, the scene is a little jarring, and a common timing mistake in television.

Vanishing Purse

Haley and Rachel didn’t spend a lot of time together throughout the series. During the fourth season of the show, though, Haley briefly tutored Rachel in math as one of the student tutors at school, the same way she met Nathan in the first season. Funnily enough, the tutoring sessions are all a ruse on Rachel’s end. Rachel doesn’t need to improve her math grades, but Brooke does. She intends to get the answers to a test for Brooke instead.

Haley and Rachel don’t usually get along, but they find some common ground, supposedly, during their tutoring sessions. Rachel even watches Haley’s purse for her at one point as they’ve “bonded.” When Rachel hands Haley her purse as Haley leaves the cafe, Haley grabs it from her and heads out. When Haley actually leaves the café in another shot, though, the purse is nowhere to be seen.

Visible Set

Today, plenty of television series film on location. One Tree Hill was filmed in the North Carolina town of Wilmington (the same town that played home to all of the drama on Dawson’s Creek). The scenes inside the high school, however, were filmed on a sound stage instead of on location.

Many fans didn’t know that Tree Hill High was actually a series of carefully constructed rooms. They could tell during a season four episode, though, when they could actually see part of the set. Following a trip to the hospital, Lucas hallucinated his uncle Keith in the hallway in a dream state. He followed him through the high school’s halls, but there was no ceiling to the hallway, only the lighting fixtures of the set hanging down. If the shot from the camera wasn’t so wide, the open ceiling wouldn’t have been so visible.

Jimmy And Keith Share A Significant Date

One of the landmark episodes of the series, and one of the most divisive among fans, featured Jimmy Edwards bringing a loaded weapon to school. While he didn’t initially intend to hurt anyone other than himself, his decision led to a schoolwide lockdown. The events of the episode saw Peyton wounded, Hayley and Nathan held hostage, and the loss of a One Tree Hill major character.

While Jimmy lost his life during the storyline, so did Lucas and Nathan’s uncle Keith Scott. Dan took advantage of the day and used it to end his big brother’s life. When Lucas visits their graves in later episodes, there is something of a discrepancy. Keith’s date of death was in January, while Jimmy’s was in March. However, that was impossible since they both died in the halls of the high school on the exact same day.

A Fake Baby Bump

One Tree Hill surprised its audience when it had two teenagers get married, and then surprised them again by having the married couple expect a baby. In their senior year of high school. Haley was pregnant with Nathan’s son. The actress, Bethany Joy Lenz, would actually marry and have kids over the course of the show, but she wasn’t pregnant at the time of the storyline. That meant that when she played Haley, she wore various prosthetic pregnancy bellies throughout the arc.

In the season four episode “Pictures of You”, Haley and Skills are paired for a class assignment. They spend time on the roof of the school with Skills lamenting his post-school prospects and Haley comforting him. It’s a fun scene since the two aren’t often paired for scenes, but it also features an error in the show. While laying back on the roof, fans could see the prosthetic belly under the edge of Haley’s top, revealing the magic of television as not so magical.

Two Different Pairs Of Shoes

Though actresses might wear platforms or spiked heels for a costume on camera, they don’t have to keep them on for 12-hour shooting days. Instead, they might throw on slippers or sneakers (or, in the case of Nicola Coughlan on Bridgerton, Crocs) between takes. Downtown between scenes, or being made up in the makeup trailer, or waiting for lighting to be fully set up, can last a long time, so sometimes, those shoes stay on and get caught on camera.

In the season four finale, the main female characters of the series wound up performing a nostalgia-tinged dance number to the Spice Girls’ song “Wannabe”. During the sequence, multiple camera angles revealed Haley had two different pairs of shoes. While in some shots, she wore heels, in others, she had sneakers on. The sneakers were likely much more comfortable and the sequence was likely filmed several times.

Visible Equipment

The fifth season of One Tree Hill jumped forward in time so that the series skipped right over the university years of its main characters. The time jump meant that the actors were all closer in age to the characters they were playing and it also meant that some new faces joined the show. As the season unfolded, musician Kate Voegele joined the cast as a singer/songwriter Haley and Peyton mentored.

In the episode “In Da Club”, Peyton blindsides Mia into opening for a band at the last minute. A lot of Mia’s time in the episode is spent nervously arguing that she can’t do it. When she finally makes the decision to go on stage, a microphone from the camera crew drops down into the shot. Because Mia is on stage with a bunch of other equipment for the band, it’s entirely likely that most fans won’t catch it the first time they watch the episode.

Changing Coffee Levels

One of the most memorable characters in One Tree Hill, for better or worse, is Nanny Carrie. The nanny hired by Nathan and Haley to help out with their son becomes enamored with the entire Scott family and eventually tries to usurp Haley’s place in the household, even going so far as abducting Jamie. Before she went that far, though, she was just a young woman crushing on her boss, Nathan Scott.

In one scene early in season five, Carrie makes coffee after spending the night out partying. While talking with Nathan about all of her flirting, she holds the coffee pot in front of her. Throughout the scene, the level of coffee in the pot changes without her pouring any out or adding to it. It’s a harmless mistake that likely means the sequence was shot in its entirety, with her actually pouring some coffee, multiple times.

Jamie’s Birthday Moves

One Tree Hill surprised audiences by having Haley and Nathan marry in high school. They surprised audiences further by making Haley become pregnant her senior year. She went into labor on her graduation day during her valedictorian speech. All that is to say that Haley’s pregnancy running the length of the school and Jamie being born as her graduation gift means that Jamie was likely born in May when most high schools hold their graduations. He could have been born in June if Tree Hill held their ceremony even later.

In season five, when Jamie celebrates a birthday, though, the comment is made that there are still 11 basketball games left in the high school season. If Jamie was born in May or June, that would be impossible. The season would already be over. Most high school basketball teams begin their season in November and run through March. The season could start a little earlier or a little later in some cases. It could also last longer thanks to tournaments or championships, but even then, it would have been done before his birthday.

The Impossible Video Game

Jamie gets a video game system for his birthday in season five. By season seven, he knows his way around several games as any child of his generation would quickly adjust to the technology at hand. Nathan spends the entire day in episode 19 of the season hanging out with his son. Among their many activities is playing the video game Rock Band with the complete setup. There’s just one problem: the way they play the game is impossible.

They have everything plugged in and ready, but as they actually play the game, viewers might notice something suspicious. The TV they play the game on? It’s turned off during part of the scene.

Now, in television, it’s often true that there is nothing on a computer or television screen. The image on the screen is added by an effects team after filming. That may have initially been the intention with the filming of the video game sequence here.

A Name Change

Some fans might not notice when the names used for buildings or street signs change in a television series. After all, a sign in the background is simply there to add realism to the scene, not necessarily for fans to keep track of the names of places, though that is certainly a fun pastime for some fans who want to completely map out a fictional location. Eagle-eyed fans will notice when a mistake is made from one shot of a sign to the next, though.

During the season three finale, Rachel and Cooper are in a car that goes off a bridge. Its name is the Molina Bridge. Five seasons later, however, there’s a name change to that very same bridge. When Brooke and Jamie go off the bridge, it’s called the Gable Bridge instead. No reason for the name change is ever made in-universe.

A New Zip Code

With fictional towns in stories, zip codes, phone numbers, and street names get invented by writers to give them a more realistic feel. They don’t want to use real phone numbers, for example, because that could create problems for the person who has the number. Real zipcodes and street names might be used for locations that also exist in the real world, but for fictional towns, new ones are created. One Tree Hill’s zip code was 01982 when Brooke addressed a letter in one episode, but it didn’t stay that way.

When Sam entered Brooke’s life as a foster daughter, letters arrived for her in the mail. Those letters featured a different zip code: 01928. The final two numbers are juxtaposed, so it’s likely this was simply a mistake in the props department. Such a slight difference wasn’t something that too many fans noticed.

Age Is Nothing But A Number

With nine seasons and a multi-year time jump in the middle, there were bound to be a few timeline issues in the show. One of the biggest ones is the ages of the characters. Throughout the early seasons of the show, Brooke was always mentioned as being a year older than Haley. Just as Haley and Nathan celebrate their seven-year anniversary, though, that changes.

When they celebrate their seven-year anniversary, according to the show’s established timeline, it should actually be their sixth. Likewise, Brooke is revealed to be a year younger than Haley as a result, which doesn’t make any sense. Either someone wasn’t keeping track of dates behind the scenes, or a decision was made to change the timeline slightly on One Tree Hill for a reason the fans don’t know about.