10 Best Shows Like Netflixs A Good Girls Guide To Murder

Summary

• Dive into more murder mysteries like
  A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder
  with shows that blend teen angst with dark themes.
• The best follow-ups are those centered around young people uncovering long-held secrets or crimes in intriguing ways.
• For a more mature twist, check out shows like
  The Afterparty
  ,
  Yellowjackets
  , or
  Tell Me Lies
  .

For those who enjoyed Netflix’s teen mystery, A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, there are plenty of great shows just like it streaming right now. A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder tells the story of Pip, a teenager who is hauntedby a murder that occurred five years ago. As a result, Pip dives deep into the case, determined to solve it, no matter the risks. A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder is a book-to-TV adaptation, with the story starting out as a trilogy written by Holly Jackson. Now, Wednesday’s Emma Myers brings the story to life.

A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder is firmly set in the young adult genre, but it definitely delves into darker themes that grip adults as much as adolescents. Furthermore, the show is a drama, but it also includes some moments of comedy, as Pip makes mistakes and deals with her regular life outside her murder investigation. All in all, the best murder mysteries to watch, like A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder are those that follow young people trying to uncover a long-kept secret or crime. The following shows may vary in genre and story, but they are great follow-ups.

10 The Afterparty (2022)

A High School Reunion Turns Into An Investigation

For those seeking a more comedic and mature version of A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, The Afterparty is the ideal choice. The mystery comedy is set at the afterparty of a high school reunion. Each episode of The Afterparty follows the perspective of a new character and how they experienced the night. Ultimately, each episode adds to the overarching mystery until it is eventually solved at the very end. The cast includes stars like Tiffany Haddish, Sam Richardson, Ben Schwartz, Ilana Glazer, and Dave Franco.

The Afterparty is a great follow-up to A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder because it gives a unique take on the classic murder mystery. While A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder’s cast are high schoolers solving a mystery, The Afterparty follows a similar plot, but aged up and in a completely new format. Audiences will still get the satisfaction of a mystery solved, but in a way they may not have expected.

9 Harlan Coben’s Shelter (2023)

High Schoolers Look Into The Disappearance Of Their Classmate

An engaging teenage mystery with a supernatural twist is Harlan Coben’s Shelter. The 2023 series is based on Harlan Coben’s book of the same name and follows Mickey, a teenage boy who moves to a new town after his father’s untimely death. However, Mickey quickly begins to notice some strange occurrences around his new town. With the help of two other outcasts, Mickey tries to figure out how these oddities connect to the disappearance of his classmate, Ashley.

However,
Harlan Coben’s Shelter
is also good because of the ways it differs from
A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder.

In many ways, Harlan Coben’s Shelter and A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder are alike. Both focus on teens who find themselves involved in a web of secrets and mysteries. However, Harlan Coben’s Shelter is also good because of the ways it differs from A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder. For those who enjoy a supernatural twist, Harlan Coben’s Shelter can provide the spooky characters and dashes of horror that Netflix’s new teen mystery may not have.

8 School Spirits (2023)

A Teenage Ghost Tries To Solve Her Murder

Another young adult mystery with a supernatural twist is Netflix’s School Spirits. This paranormal drama follows Maddie, a teenage girl who unexpectedly becomes a ghost haunting her high school. Although the other ghosts encourage Maddie to accept her fate, she becomes obsessed with figuring out what happened to her. Eventually, Maddie realizes that her murder may not be as straightforward as it might have originally seemed.

Just like A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder’s biggest mysteries, School Spirits provides an amazing twist that will leave audiences thinking about it for days afterward. The show provides an interesting world wherein Maddie learns about her ghost peers and their pasts, but it also maintains the mystery of Maddie’s death until the very end. School Spirits is a truly complex and mind-bending drama with a stellar cast and a notable soundtrack. It is definitely worth watching, especially for those who enjoyed A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder.

7 Yellowjackets (2021)

A Soccer Team Is Stuck In The Wilderness

A mystery that perfectly balances teenage angst with more mature themes is Yellowjackets. This paranormal horror series follows two timelines: a girl’s soccer team as they crash-land in the wilderness, and the same girls 20 years later. Through these time jumps, audiences must figure out how the team survived their plane crash. More importantly, though, viewers must learn about the strange and intense powers that overcame the girls during their isolation.

Yellowjackets is a twisty and creepy series that is a must-watch for those who want a more mature version of A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder. Notably, Yellowjackets can be quite grim and scary, but all of it is worth it in order to uncover what really happened to the Yellowjackets soccer team. On top of that, the Yellowjackets’ cast provides amazing performances from actors such as Melanie Lynskey, Christina Ricci, and Ella Purnell. All in all, it is a mystery series that is certainly worth the hype.

6 Elite (2018)

Private School Students Become Involved In Dark Situations

At first glance, Elite may not seem very similar to A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, but in reality, the shows share many common threads. Elite is a Spanish young adult drama that follows three working-class teens as they are given scholarships to attend a prestigious private school. Upon arrival, the students clash with their wealthy peers, but also find solace and intimacy with others. In eight seasons, Elite showcases the highs and lows of this unique high school.

Elite
premiered its eighth and final season in July 2024.

Though Elite seems like any other teenage show, it actually has plenty of mystery as well. Like A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, the series presents tragedies that its characters must uncover piece by piece. Elite succeeds at combining stereotypical teenage problems with much larger catastrophic issues. Additionally, Elite is a standout because of the ways it tackles important issues such as class, race, and sexuality. With eight seasons under its belt, there is certainly a reason the show continued has for so long.

5 Tell Me Lies (2022)

A College Student’s Toxic Relationship Hides Horrifying Crimes

Another show that is slightly aged-up from A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder is Tell Me Lies. This mystery show, based on the novel of the same name by Carola Lovering, follows Lucy, a college student who falls into an intense relationship with Stephen. Their bond is toxic and unhealthy, but the secrets hidden behind their relationship, including a murder, don’t truly come out until many years later.

Tell Me Lies
is as if
A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder
occurred during college rather than high school.

Like Elite, Tell Me Lies is bursting with the expected teenage angst, yet its mystery is what sets it apart. Tell Me Lies is dark, intense, and at times, scary. Tell Me Lies is as if A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder occurred during college rather than high school. However, one thing remains irrevocably different. Where Pip is an outside observer to the crimes in A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, Tell Me Lies focuses heavily on Lucy and Stephen’s relationship and their participation in whatever wrongdoings occurred during their college years.

4 Cruel Summer (2021)

Teens Face Traumatic Circumstances Over Several Years

A teen murder mystery with a nostalgic setting is Cruel Summer. This anthology series follows a new mystery every season surrounding teenagers in the 1990s and early 2000s. The first season of Cruel Summer follows friends Kate and Jeanette. After Kate goes missing, socially awkward Jeanette blossoms and takes on aspects of Kate’s life. However, when Kate is found, Jeanette’s role in her disappearance comes into question.

Cruel Summer is perfect for those who love pulpy young adult series. Within the show’s two seasons, there are plenty of dramatic twists and turns to keep audiences invested. The 90s setting definitely makes the show even more enticing and aesthetically pleasing. Furthermore, the series is well-liked, with a 94% on Rotten Tomatoes. Boasting a cast of talented young actors and plenty of juicy storytelling, Cruel Summer is a strong contender over A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder.

3 One Of Us Is Lying (2021)

Kids In Detention Are Suspects In A Murder

One of Us Is Lying is like a modern The Breakfast Club, but with murder. The story, based on a novel of the same name by Karen M. McManus, follows five high schoolers who are put in detention together. While there, one of the students, who runs an online gossip column, dies of an allergic reaction that they discover was not an accident. Each of the four remaining teens has a motive to kill their classmate, so to clear their names, they must work together to find out who the real killer is.

In many ways, One of Us Is Lying is just like A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder. Both shows are book-to-TV adaptations about high schoolers solving murders. There is teenage drama, angst, romance, and high stakes. Yet, One of Us Is Lying is particularly fun because of its group dynamics. Rather than focusing on just one trustworthy main character, audiences are forced to decide who they trust and who could be lying. This makes the mystery even more intense and exciting to solve.

2 Veronica Mars (2004)

A Teen Detective Digs Into LA Mysteries

When discussing young adult mysteries, it would be wrong to omit one of the classics of the genre: Veronica Mars. Starring Kristen Bell, the 2004 TV series follows Veronica, a teenager who used to be at the top of the social pyramid, but fell from grace after a series of personal traumas. As a result, Veronica leaves behind her high school drama and begins assisting her private investigator father in unraveling the mysteries of the Los Angeles elite.

Audiences who love murder mysteries have to check out Veronica Mars. It may be 20 years old, but the series still holds up as a solid representation of young adult storytelling and intriguing mystery. Kristen Bell is a joy to watch as the snarky and sarcastic Veronica. Furthermore, the first three seasons have 20 episodes or more, giving audiences plenty of content to enjoy. For a blast from the past, Veronica Mars is the way to go.

1 Wednesday (2022)

Wednesday Addams Goes To Magical High School

The final show that viewers must check out after A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder may be the most obvious. Before Emma Myers starred as Pip in A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, she appeared in her breakout role as Enid in Netflix’s Wednesday. This hit horror comedy follows the iconic Wednesday Addams as she is forced to attend a magical boarding school. Wednesday is desperate to leave, but she soon becomes involved in a murder investigation that she is desperate to solve.

Wednesday
season 2 is currently in production but has no official release date yet.

The most obvious connection between Wednesday and A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder is Emma Myers. Yet, the shows are akin in other ways as well. Both have dark undertones and an exciting central mystery. A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder may not have quirky paranormal characters, but the cast of characters is still unique and fun to watch. Overall, Wednesday is a fantastic watch no matter what, due to its mix of humor, darkness, and beloved characters.