10 Murder Mysteries Where You Can Guess The Killer Almost Right Away

The following article contains discussions of sexual violence, suicidal ideation, addiction, murder, graphic themes, kidnapping, and stalking.



To unravel an intricate web of mysteries, immersion in the process is crucial. The art of sleuthing demands sharp observational skills and keen intuition, allowing the investigator to piece together clues meticulously. Each fragment, no matter how small, holds the potential to lead to the culprit behind the crime, igniting a journey filled with suspense and discovery. However, certain ways of shaping a story tend to make some culprits more obvious than others, making it less difficult to uncover the killer.


Well-known characters such as Hercule Poirot and Benoit Blanc are features of the engaging whodunit genre, including popular franchises like Knives Out. The classic framework of a whodunit can sometimes constrain the richness of murder mysteries, yet it simultaneously provides a clearer path to uncovering the killer’s identity. This familiar format, with its set clues and defining suspect characteristics, streamlines the sleuthing process and creates an engagement in the thrill of deduction following the plot’s twists and turns.



10 Death On The Nile (2022)

Killer: Jacqueline de Bellefort (Emma Mackey)

Kenneth Branagh reprises his role as Hercule Poirot for the second time in this Agatha Christie adaptation. Death on the Nile is a sequel to the 2017 movie Murder on the Orient Express and a prequel to the 2023 movie A Haunting in Venice. In the film, the Belgian detective navigates captivating characters and intricate scenarios with the focus of uncovering the chilling truths behind a clever killer. An emphasis on the power of love leading to negative actions is evident throughout the film and in the lives of Death on the Nile‘s characters.


The constant attention to love and overt foreshadowing suggest the killer’s identity early on. Jacqueline de Bellefort’s (Emma Mackey) commitment to ex-boyfriend Simon Doyle (Armie Hammer) is notable from the very beginning and reverberates through the movie as she desperately makes her presence known to win him back after marrying the wealthy heiress Linnet Ridgeway (Gal Gadot). Jacqueline’s reveal as the killer is predictable, as is her partnership with Simon, explaining her consistent presence around them and showcasing her persistent desire to regain his love.

9 Gone Baby Gone (2007)

Killer: Remy Bressant (Ed Harris)


In Gone Baby Gone, Casey Affleck portrays an exceptional detective, Patrick Kenzie. Patrick is put through several tests while cooperating with the police department to find Helene McCready’s (Amy Ryan) four-year-old daughter. With several moments in mind, it is easy enough to realize that the police department is both the killer and the kidnapper. This perception of officers undermines the integrity of law enforcement while spotlighting the complex reality of making the right decisions. A thought-provoking story about morals and ethics, excellent performances, and Ben Affleck’s skillful direction make Gone Baby Gone a remarkable movie.

The sudden influx of evidence, supposedly linked to drug lord Cheese (Edi Gathegi), creates skepticism surrounding the case. As Detective Remy Bressant (Ed Harris) drunkenly reveals his past connection to a suspect and admits to planting evidence for the protection of a child, a question about credibility forms, confirming Patrick’s confusion about the unsuccessful attempt to save Amanda McCready (Madeline O’Brien). The murder of Police Captain Jack Doyle’s (Morgan Freeman) daughter and Devin’s (Michael Kenneth Williams) warning to Patrick about the repercussions of delving into police affairs supports the truth about Cheese’s death and Amanda’s abduction.


8 Taking Lives (2004)

Killer: James Costa (Ethan Hawke)

Taking Lives

Director
D.J. Caruso

Release Date
March 19, 2004

Runtime
100 minutes

Main Genre
Mystery

Taking Lives effectively creates red herrings, instilling a false sense of security and distracting several people, including FBI agent Illeana Scott (Angelina Jolie). Every agent or detective employs unique methods, and Illeana’s immersive and consistent approach to trying to get into the mind of the Montreal serial killer creates an essential profile with characteristics. Murder witness James Costa (Ethan Hawke) disrupts Illeana’s focus with continuous comfort, which is especially valuable in a hostile police station. Hawke effectively captures the despicable nature of the serial killer, Martin Asher, as he adopts various personalities, including that of James Costa.


Split image showing Ethan Hawke in Great Expectations and Daybreakers.

10 Most Underrated Ethan Hawke Roles

Ethan Hawke’s been an A-list actor for 30 years, but that doesn’t mean that he doesn’t have a few underrated performances.

The script’s inclusion of the character and his transformation results in a chilling yet captivating experience that is predictable with several clues. Despite Costa’s portrayal of a romantic interest in Illeana, his frequent appearances around her leave no room for mere coincidences while continuously employing tactics to lower her guard. Other hints include Director D.J. Caruso’s choices, such as the Dutch angle when Costa embraces his reality while gaining knowledge about his next victim and personality and the vertigo effect to emphasize Illeana’s shocking discoveries about Costa, which add to the intensity of the scenes.


7 Insomnia (2002)

Killer: Walter Finch (Robin Williams)

Insomnia - Poster

Insomnia, directed by Christopher Nolan, follows two Los Angeles homicide detectives sent to a northern town where the sun never sets to investigate the meticulous murder of a local teenager. The incessant daylight plays a critical role in the unraveling of the case and the psychological dynamics between the characters.

Release Date
May 24, 2002

Writers
Hillary Seitz , Nikolaj Frobenius , Erik Skjoldbjærg

Insomnia is an underrated movie by Christopher Nolan, a sentiment the respectable director recognizes himself. However, the reveal of Walter Finch (Robin Williams) being Kay Connell’s (Yan-Kay Crystal Lowe) killer is obvious after a blatant confession and quick connection, when the focus shifts to the possibility of an arrest. However, Detective Will Dormer (Al Pacino) being a killer and developing a relationship with Finch is less predictable, but some hints showcase dishonest ways. After mistakenly murdering his partner, Hap Eckhart (Martin Donovan), Dormer spirals into more deceitful acts.


Dormer’s firm disagreement about Eckhart cutting a deal with the Internal Affairs investigators creates questions about the credibility of his life’s work. Dormer tampers with evidence, lies to Eckhart’s family, and initially forms an agreement with Finch, who thinks his killing is an accident as well. Dormer couldn’t sleep due to the effects of “white nights” in Nightmute, contributing to the haunting guilt as he hides in the darkness before a point of redemption in Insomia’s ending scene.

6 Watcher (2022)

Killer: Watcher (Burn Gorman)


In Watcher, a serial killer known as “The Spider,” who has a pattern of cuts, terrorizes the Bucharest neighborhood where the newly relocated couple Julia (Maika Monroe) and Francis (Karl Glusman) live. The former actress finds herself in a predicament when she notices a particular Watcher by the name of Daniel Weber (Burn Gorman) fixating on her from the opposing apartment building. Watcher is distinct from the 2022 release of a similar name, The Watcher. While both works explore the concept of “people watching,” they present distinct narratives and details that differentiate them.

Title

Type

Release Date

IMDb Rating

Watcher

Movie

June 3, 2022

6.3/10

The Watcher

Series

October 13, 2022

6.5/10

In the movie, the killer is predictable because he always wears the same jacket, and Julia feels an eerie sensation around or concerning him despite his face remaining a mystery for some time. Julia’s unemployment, the language barrier she faces, and her husband’s demanding job leave her alone for much of the time. This isolation heightens her encounters with the watcher, including a threatening conversation involving a head in a grocery bag on an immovable train. These experiences amplify her belief that the watcher is the killer.


5 Knives Out (2019)

Killer: Ransom Drysdale (Chris Evans)

In Knives Out, Benoit Blanc (Daniel Craig) takes on a case from a member of the Thrombey family to investigate the circumstances surrounding the death of the patriarch, Harlan Thrombey (Christopher Plummer). During the initial interrogation, a week after Harlan’s passing, hints about Ransom Drysdale (Chris Evans) emerge. In mysteries, every little detail is important, as Ransom becomes significant after the subtle mentions. The intricate hidden details in Knives Out significantly elevate the film’s captivating murder mystery, showcasing Rian Johnson’s exceptional writing and direction.


Collage of Ready or Not, Knives Out, and Sherlock Holmes

22 Best Movies Like Knives Out

Rian Johnson’s smash-hit murder mystery film Knives Out is a fun, comforting, hilarious watch, and there are plenty of enjoyable movies like it.

The Thrombey family recognizes Ransom’s unstable relationship with his grandfather Harlan, and Benoit likens it to a relationship between “drama mamas” who enjoy fighting each other. Ransom is a selfish character, which is evident through his rudeness and his plot to frame Marta Cabrera (Ana de Armas). In light of his plan failing and despite his family’s losses, he devises a plan to help Marta in exchange for a portion of the fortune. Ransom’s personality, actions, and willingness to murder anyone who stands in his way make his reveal as the killer unsurprising.

4 The Pale Blue Eye (2022)

Killer: Augustus Landor (Christian Bale)


The Pale Blue Eye is one of Netflix’s underrated original movies. Augustus Landor (Christian Bale), a seasoned retired detective, diligently works with cadet Edgar Allan Poe (Harry Melling) through an “air of concealed violence” to uncover the truth behind the disturbing killings at a U.S. military academy. Landor’s reveal as The Pale Blue Eye killer is predictable due to certain scenes and Bale’s moving performance. Landor’s opinion about the academy making inhumane men, his acceptance to work for free, the easy identification of a contusion, and more create a suspicious focus on the character.


Despite his familiarity with others and Poe, who discovers his identity after enduring intense suspicion, Landor feels alone after both his wife and daughter die. The academy’s summon creates an opportunity for Landor’s revenge quest for his daughter, Mattie (Hadley Robinson). In hopes of avenging Mattie, a victim of rape by three cadets, Landor sets out to find those three men. Landor’s painful trauma creates an unsympathetic and often unemotional character in him as he hopes the last man he’s unable to kill lives in fear for the rest of his days.

3 Disturbia (2007)

Killer: Robert Turner (David Morse)


Disturbia’s arrival on Netflix has reignited discussions about its inspirations, particularly highlighting the influence of Alfred Hitchcock’s classic 1954 film Rear Window and other iconic thrillers. In the movie, after experiencing a car accident, watching his father’s tragic death, and committing assault to protect his father’s name, Kale Brecht (Shia LaBeouf) receives three months of house arrest, resulting in his watching “reality without the TV.”

During a watch, he discovers questionable behavior from Robert Turner (David Morse), leading to observations with Kale and his friends, Ashley (Sarah Roemer) and Ronnie (Aaron Yoo). The initial petty affair becomes a critical one as Kale’s boredom transforms into doing the good deed of identifying and killing the serial killer. Robert Turner being the killer is predictable as the initial and only suspect becomes the culprit, confirming the intimidation and claims of watching them as well.


2 Murder By Numbers (2002)

Killer: Justin Pendleton (Michael Pitt)

With a perturbing opener, Murder by Numbers creates a gripping start to a devastating story despite being one of Sandra Bullock’s underrated movies. During a murder investigation, Detective Cassie Mayweather (Sandra Bullock) encounters two wealthy high schoolers, Richard Haywood (Ryan Gosling) and Justin Pendleton (Michael Pitt). The teenagers have a relationship to replace the neglect from their parents, but they hurt each other, and their boredom leads to the evil plan of murdering random women.

Cassie’s annoyance with Richard stems from his narcissistic behavior, similar to her abusive ex-husband’s. As the duo’s involvement is obvious, the question about the killer between them arises. Justin being the killer contradicts Cassie’s view of Richard, but is easy to guess considering the scene where Justin hits Richard and his desire for Richard’s approval as the popular guy in high school.


1 Murder Mystery 2 (2023)

Killer: Countess Sekou (Jodie Turner-Smith)

In Murder Mystery 2, Nick Spitz (Adam Sandler) and Audrey Spitz (Jennifer Aniston) accept an invitation to The Maharajah’s (Adeel Akhtar) wedding. The couple encounter Countess Sekou (Jodie Turner-Smith), who eventually reveals herself as the killer despite an ongoing kidnapping. The Countess being a killer is fairly simple to figure out, considering her continuous condescending remarks about the Spitzs. Her inability to accept the Spitzs handling the grand ransom payment leads to her plan to steal from them and leave them to die.


Like a villain, the Countess has a memorable sidekick, as others refer to her. Imani (Zurin Villanueva) rarely speaks words of her own, often snickering or echoing what the Countess says, but during the betrayal scene, she defines her identity by shooting the Countess back and announcing a “triple cross,” a surprising moment in Murder Mystery 2.

Fuente

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR