All 11 Jim Carrey Movies From The 1990s, Ranked

Jim Carrey was one of the most famous comedy actors of the 1990s, whose acclaimed film roles have remained cornerstones of popular culture. With a bombastic and over-the-top comedic style, Carrey’s unique blend of physical humor, contorted facial expressions, distinctive vocal inflections, and slapstick mannerisms meant he appealed to viewers of all ages who connected with his outrageous brand of comedy. Adding to this, Carrey had real skill as a dramatic actor, and as the 1990s progressed, he began tackling more challenging, layered, and thought-provoking film roles.

Many of the best Jim Carrey movies were released during the 1990s, and in 1994 alone, he had three of his biggest successes following the back-to-back releases of Ace Ventura: Pet Detective, The Mask, and Dumb and Dumber. Carrey’s powerful performances in the biopic Man on the Moon and the insightful satire The Truman Show also meant he stood out among other comedy actors during this era. The 1990s was a fantastic time in Carrey’s career that was packed with memorable and still beloved movies.

11 Simon Birch (1998)

Jim Carrey as Adult Joe Wenteworth / Narrator

The overtly sentimental Simon Birch was somewhat of an anomaly in Jim Carrey’s 1990s career. As a mushy story that focused more on pulling on the viewer’s heartstrings than telling a truly compelling narrative, Simon Birth told the story of 12-year-old Joe Wenteworth and his best friend Simon Birch, a boy born with dwarfism. As two oddball kids who found meaningful friendship with one another, Carrey played the grown-up version of Joe and narrated this unabashedly melodramatic tearjerker.

While some viewers might connect with young Simon, an eccentric boy whose big personality more than made up for his small stature, others will see Simon Birch’s story of faith and friendship as emotionally manipulative. In truth, Simon Birch was too sweet for its own good and crumbled under the weight of its bloated, nearly two-hour runtime. While Carrey’s narration added some depth and humanity to this narrative, Simon Birch was a far cry from his more acclaimed dramatic work in the 2000s, such as Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind.

10 Batman Forever (1995)

Jim Carrey as Edward Nygma / The Riddler

Jim Carrey’s oddball eccentricities felt like the perfect addition to Joel Schumacher’s Batman Forever, which continued Tim Burton’s series and recast Michael Keaton’s Batman with Val Kilmer. As the tone of this franchise continued to become increasingly campy, Carrey’s over-the-top characterization of Edward Nygma fit right in, and he gave himself entirely to the outrageous nature of his character. It was thrilling to watch Carrey play the former Wayne Enterprises employee who, after his invention was personality rejected by Bruce Wayne, transformed into the puzzle-obsessed supervillain.

As a bright, funny, and fast-paced adaptation of the DC hero, Batman Forever had far more in common with the 1960s Adam West series than the future dark reimagining of the franchise by Christopher Nolan. While it’s easier to criticize Batman Forever for not standing up against the best cinematic renditions of the Caped Crusader, for the movie he was in, Carrey did a fantastic job. Between Carrey’s characterization of The Riddler and Tommy Lee Jones’ hilarious portrayal of Two-Face, Batman Forever was a lot of fun.

9 Doing Time On Maple Drive (1992)

Jim Carrey as Tim Carter

As Jim Carrey’s first truly dramatic role, it’s impossible not to compare Doing Time on Maple Drive to later movies like The Truman Show or Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind that highlighted his talents outside of comedy. While Carrey’s role as Tim Carter doesn’t quite live up to those parts, it was an earlier indication he was interested in broadening his horizons and had more to offer than his over-the-top comedic persona. However, to truly show his skill, Carrey needed better material than this made-for-TV movie about a seemingly perfect family whose dysfunctionality was buried just below the surface.

Carrey gave a straight-laced performance as Tim Carter, an alcoholic college dropout whose drinking was getting out of control and harbored a resentful relationship with his unlikable father. While it’s interesting to see Carrey shed his comic persona and prove his dramatic acting chops, the real focus of Doing Time on Maple Drive was Tim’s closeted younger brother Matt (William McNamara), whose secret homosexuality unraveled the family’s hidden dysfunction. Overall, Doing Time on Maple Drive just felt a little contrived, and the most notable thing about this made-for-TV movie was seeing Carrey’s dramatic debut.

8 Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls (1995)

Jim Carrey as Ace Ventura

For the majority of his career, Jim Carrey has avoided sequels, with one notable exception being Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls. As Carrey’s breakout role, it made sense that he returned to Ace Ventura, although it quickly became apparent that the joke didn’t work twice and that this series offered diminishing returns. While there were still plenty of hilarious, over-the-top antics, they just didn’t land as hard as in the original, and it was difficult to justify the existence of this lackluster sequel.

To make matters worse, Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls moved the action to Africa as Ace was hired to locate a missing bat. This paper-thin plotline meant that looking back on Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls through a modern lens, the racial representation was questionable at best. Carrey has explained why he has mostly avoided sequels in his career by stating that they often felt repetitive and like an imitating the original (via Comic Book), and it’s hard not to think that Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls was a primary influence on him feeling this way.

7 The Cable Guy (1996)

Jim Carrey as Chip Douglas

Jim Carrey showcased a much darker side to his comedic talents with the black comedy The Cable Guy. As the story of a regular architect named Steven (Matthew Broderick) whose life was upended after an eccentric cable installer named Chip arrived and gave him free movie channels; however, Chip was under the impression that this friendly favor now made them best friends. Chip’s overbearing, obsessive, and outrageous nature meant he quickly encroached on Steven’s life, alienating him from his friends, leaving countless messages on his answering machine, and acting increasingly clingy and bizarre.

The Cable Guy was the perfect movie for Jim Carrey, as he balanced the darkness of Chip’s character with his uniquely manic comedic skill, making him both entertaining and terrifying. While it may have alienated some viewers at the time of its release as Carrey came across as more scary than his usual goofy nature in the 1990s, The Cable Guy has since become a true cult classic. While The Cable Guy wasn’t Carrey’s greatest movie of the 1990s, it was definitely one of his most interesting that opened the door for him to pursue more serious and complex roles.

6 Ace Ventura: Pet Detective (1994)

Jim Carrey as Ace Ventura

With the release of Ace Ventura: Pet Detective, audiences were introduced to the immense talents of Jim Carrey, as he had finally found a role that played into his unique skillset. As an outrageous and over-the-top role that exploited Carrey’s talent for physical humor, exaggerated facial expressions, and energetic slapstick comedy, Ace Ventura was part that brought out the best in him and signaled the dawning of a new voice in comedy. By playing an absurd and surreal animal detective, Carrey blew audiences away as his boundless energy appeared to have no limits.

Ace Ventura: Pet Detective was a spoof of detective movies strung together by raunchy humor and gross-out comedy that highlighted Carrey as a love-him-or-hate-him kind of character actor. While the representation of a transgender villain and some homophobic language dated Ace Ventura: Pet Detective, this does not overshadow it as a defining film in Jim Carrey’s career, which launched him as a major comedy actor. The role of Ace Ventura was a star-making performance, and it’s no surprise that Carrey continued his hot streak with two more iconic performances in 1994 alone.

5 Dumb and Dumber (1994)

Jim Carrey as Lloyd Christmas

While Jim Carrey’s bombastic style often overshadowed everybody else in his movies, in Dumb and Dumber he proved himself an excellent addition to a comedic duo. With Carrey as Lloyd Christmas and Jeff Daniels as Harry Dunne, this Farrelly Brothers farce starred the pair as two dimwitted best friends embroiled on a cross-country road trip of hilarious misadventure. With incredible chemistry, Carrey and Daniels brought to mind an older age of slapstick comedy where physical humor had audiences splitting their sides due to the intensity of the hilarious antics on screen.

While Dumb and Dumber was silly and stupid, its extreme comedy was so over-the-top that it went full circle to being so ridiculous it actually came across as clever. From Carrey improvising the most annoying sound in the world to Daniels getting his tongue stuck on a frozen pole, Dumb and Dumber was ride-splittingly funny and a film that viewers of all ages could enjoy. With Carrey in top comedic form and Daniels as one of the few actors capable of matching his energy, Dumb and Dumber was one of the best comedies of the 1990s.

4 The Mask (1994)

Jim Carrey as Stanley Ipkiss / The Mask

Jim Carrey always had a cartoonish, comic book-like energy, which is why his starring role in The Mask was a truly inspired casting decision. As a film based on the comic book series of the same name, The Mask allowed Carrey to take his outrageous style into extremities never before seen as the down-on-his-luck bank employee Stanley Ipkiss encountered a magical mask that transformed him into the titular green-faced, zoot-suit wearing trickster. Through the use of visuals, The Mask could bend reality at his will, as his overly animated characterization made for hilarious viewing.

The Mask was Carrey’s comedy style condensed to its purest form, and it’s hard to imagine this concept working with any other actor, as proven by the lackluster standalone sequel Son of the Mask. Carrey excelled alongside Cameron Diaz as his love interest, Tina Carlyle, whose striking beauty and incredible cinematic charm made her role one of the most memorable film debuts of all time. While Carrey had some more acclaimed films in this decade, The Mask truly encapsulated the hilarious comedian’s appeal during this era and why he became one of the most successful comedy actors of the 1990s.

3 Liar Liar (1997)

Jim Carrey as Fletcher Reede

Liar Liar expanded upon Carrey’s incredible comedic charm with a heartfelt, insightful, and poignant story. Carrey played workaholic divorced lawyer Fletcher Reede, whose career and personal life consistently took precedence over his young child, and after missing his son’s birthday party, his life was upended when the boy’s wish that for one day his dad could never tell a lie came true. This unique concept led to hilarious circumstances as Fletcher was compelled to reveal his hypocrisy by telling the truth no matter how badly it affected his job, personal life, or relationships.

As a truly funny movie, Liar Liar was also a vulnerable story about a dad who has one last chance to reconnect with his son before ruining their relationship permanently. While Carrey’s physical comedy and skill for slapstick were on full display, Liar Liar never lost sight of the moral lessons at the center of its story and the importance of putting family before work. As Carrey’s career moved into a more sentimental space in the late 1990s, Liar Liar’s more affecting nature meant it rose above the more outrageous entries in his career’s filmography, like Ace Ventura and The Mask.

2 Man on the Moon (1999)

Jim Carrey as Andy Kaufman

While Jim Carrey gained worldwide recognition for playing outrageous and unrealistic comedy characters, it was a testament to Andy Kaufman’s uniqueness that one of his strange roles was actually based on a real person. Kaufman was one of the forebearers of Carrey’s distinctive style, and he played the often-dubbed ‘anti-comedian’ in the unusual biopic Man on the Moon. to perfection. This marked Carrey’s first fact-based movie, and he committed entirely to the role, utilized a method acting style, and stayed in character for extended periods, as seen in the behind-the-scenes documentary Jim & Andy: The Great Beyond.

Carrey embodied Kaufman, as well as his other comedy characters, Tony Clifton and Latka Gravas, in a highly effective biopic that flopped at the box office. While this was one of the few financial failings of Carrey during the 1990s, Man on the Moon was an artistic success as he mimicked Kafuman’s mannerisms to a tee as the idiosyncratic appeal of the Saturday Night Live and Taxi star. Playing Kaufman effectively was no mean feat, and Carrey was one of the few performers in the 1990s who had the skillset to pull it off.

1 The Truman Show (1998)

Jim Carrey as Truman Burbank

The greatest Jim Carrey movie of the 1990s was undoubtedly The Truman Show, a film that has only become more relevant and thought-provoking in the years since its release. With Carrey as Truman Burbank, a man who did not know his entire life was a carefully constructed reality TV show, this psychological comedy addressed the very nature of selfhood, what constitutes real lived experience, versus orchestrated manipulation. The Truman Show highlighted Carrey’s talent as both an incredibly dramatic actor and an unmatched comedic talent.

Part of the reason The Truman Show has endured so well was the emotional rollercoaster that was Carrey’s performance and the connection viewers felt with him as he slowly started to uncover the lie that was his life. As a biting satire that, in many ways, predicted the rise of reality television, The Truman Show addressed existentialism, surveillance, and the all-consuming power of media. With his role as Truman, Jim Carrey entered a new phase of his career where he balanced his more outrageous comedic persona with insightful, personal, and highly thought-provoking film roles that balanced comedy and drama.

Source: Comic Book